The influential German winemaker
Hans-Günter Schwarz has died at the age of 84. Schwarz
passed away on Friday, November 21, 2025. He was widely regarded as a
legend in the industry and a defining shaper of the German white wine
style, known for his philosophy that great wine is primarily made in the
vineyard.
Key facts about his legacy:
Müller-Catoir: He managed the prestigious VDP winery Müller-Catoir in Neustadt an der Weinstraße for over 40 years.
Influence:
Schwarz significantly influenced the quality development of German
viticulture, acting as an indispensable mentor to a "three-digit number"
of aspiring winemakers.
Philosophy:
While other winemakers focused on technology and additives in the
cellar, Schwarz practiced "controlled idleness" in the cellar,
prioritizing precise, nature-oriented work in the vines.
Recognition:
In 1989, the influential wine critic Robert M. Parker Jr. rated his
wines highly and pronounced him "Germany's most brilliant winemaker".
During
Hans-Günter Schwarz's
tenure (which began when he was just 19 and lasted over 40 years,
ending in 2001), Müller-Catoir became renowned for producing some of
Germany's most exceptional and complex white wines, setting standards
for quality and authenticity. Key aspects of the winery's reputation during this period included:
Pioneering Reductive Winemaking:
Müller-Catoir was a pioneer of the reductive winemaking style in
Germany, which minimizes oxygen exposure during production. This
approach helped preserve the wines' freshness, purity of fruit, and
delicate aromas.
"Activism in the Vineyard, Minimalism in the Cellar":
This philosophy was the hallmark of Schwarz's approach. While other
winemakers focused on technology and additives, he emphasized
meticulous, nature-oriented work in the vines (e.g., organic
fertilization, radical green cutting, and selective hand-picking),
followed by a "controlled idleness" (minimal intervention) in the
cellar.
Exceptional Varietal Expression:
Schwarz was celebrated for his ability to clearly highlight the unique
characteristics of each grape variety. His wines, across a range of
grapes, displayed a rarely achieved finesse.
Focus on Diverse Grape Varieties:
While Riesling was central, Müller-Catoir was particularly famous for
its high-quality expressions of lesser-known or more challenging
varieties like Rieslaner and Scheurebe. Under Schwarz's hand, these grapes produced wines of remarkable complexity and aging potential.
Site-Specific Expression (Terroir):
The wines were known for their transparency, density, and distinct
mineral notes, reflecting the unique sandstone and primary rock soils of
their Haardt vineyards (e.g., Bürgergarten, Herzog).
International Recognition:
The winery gained international acclaim, notably in 1989 when critic
Robert M. Parker Jr. praised Schwarz as "Germany's most brilliant
winemaker".
In
essence, under Schwarz, Müller-Catoir was a beacon of quality in an era
of industrial winemaking, known for elegant, age-worthy wines that
prioritized vineyard health and natural winemaking processes.
Hans-Günter Schwarz served as an indispensable mentor to a large number of winemakers over his four-decade career
. Some of the prominent winemakers influenced by him include:
Jan Eymael, Hans-Jörg Rebholz (Weingut Ökonomierat Rebholz), now considered one of the greatest producers in the Pfalz region, Andreas Schumann, Frank John, Sven Leiner, Konrad Salwey, Markus Wöhrle, Julia Keller, Helmut Darting (Weingut Kurt Darting), who completed his practical studies with Schwarz at Müller-Catoir, Jim Hooper (Paetra Wine), an American winemaker who credits Schwarz with shaping his entire winemaking philosophy of minimal intervention. These
winemakers praise his expertise, collegial manner, and his emphasis on
meticulous work in the vineyard to allow the wine to essentially make
itself in the cellar, a philosophy that ran counter to the prevailing
technical winemaking trends of the time.
Vineyard Tour, Cellar Tour and Tasting at Weingut Müller Catoir – Germany-South Tour by ombiasy WineTours (2015)
See: Vineyard Tour, Cellar Tour and Tasting at Weingut Müller Catoir – Germany-South Tour by ombiasy WineTours (2015)
This outstanding, castle-like impressive estate - visible on the Haardt hill from afar - in the Neustadt suburb of Haardt, the so called balcony of the Pfalz with a very favorable microclimate, has been in the Müller-Catoir family since 1744. For more than a century the winery was managed by women who left a pronounced mark on the estate. Today ninth generation Philipp David Catoir is running the winery.
This was a “walking tasting”. We tasted the wines during the vineyard tour and the cellar tour. Andrea Müller was our host.
Weingut Müller Catoir is in the Theise/ Skurnik portfolio of German wines.
Pictures: Arriving at Weingut Müller Catoir
Weingut Müller Catoir
Theise/ Skurnik: Family owned since 1774 with 9 generations tending the vines, the winery is now run by Philipp David Catoir. Martin Franzen, hailing from the Mosel, with experience as head of operations at Schlossgut Diel in the Nahe and Gut Nagelsforst in Baden, took over winemaking responsibility from Hans-Günther Schwarz in 2001. In an effort to showcase terroir and varietal character, Müller-Catoir has adopted the following philosophy of winegrowing: “Vines were grown by natural methods with organic fertilization, permanent green cutting that gets more and more radical every summer, and ever-greater selective harvesting with hand-picking of grapes for even the most “basic” kabinett wine – all these measures cannot help but produce only a small yield of wines with a mineral note, a filigree acidity structure and exotic fruit aromas.” The estate began an organic conversion in 2007 and completed their first organic vintage in 2009. The vineyards in Haardt are composed of primary rock (urgestein) and sandstone, with an increasing proportion of gravel lower on the slopes. Vineyards of Gimmeldingen contain more loess and sand, while the vineyards of Mussbach are the most gravelly. Müller-Catoir also bottles several “micro parcels”; one of which, the Breumel in den Mauern, is a monopole inside the Burgergarten which was first planted 700 years ago, and is also one of the oldest vineyards in the Pfalz.
Pictures: Vineyard Tour and Tasting at Weingut Müller Catoir
Müller-Catoir was a pioneer of reductive winemaking in Germany. The estate implements a gentle crush, a long skin contact, slow gentle pressing, and then ferments at warmer than customary fermentation temperatures in stainless steel. The wine is racked only once and very late. Müller-Catoir produces wines of outstanding transparency and density, and remains emblematic of Riesling at its most sophisticated.
Vineyard area: 21 hectares
Annual production: 12,500 cases
Vineyard holdings: Haardt – Bürgergarten, Herzog (both sandstone) and Herrenletten (loam, limestone); Gimmeldingen – Mandelgarten (weathered sandstone and löss): Mußbach – Eselshaut (gravel)
Farming Practice: Certified Organic
Gault Millau WeinGuide Deutschland 2016
Gault Millau WeinGuide Deutschland 2016: Man darf mit Fug und Recht sagen, dass das Weingut Müller-Catoir wie ein Fels in der Brandung steht. Um es herum ist Aktion, Alarm, Mode hier, Trend dort – und Müller-Catoir in aller Ruhe mittendrin, unbeirrt seinen eigenen Stil verfolgend. Der drückt sich etwa darin aus, sich niemandem anzubiedern durch ein möglichst breit aufgestelltes Sortiment – etwas mehr als eine Handvoll Rebsorten genügen hier. Auch die Anzahl der trockenen Rieslinge ist überschaubar: vom Gutswein „MC geht es über Haardt, Bürgergarten und Herrenletten schnurstracks zum Großen Gewächs Im Breumel. Alles fein und klar definiert, durchaus aristokratisch zu nennen. Unglaublich strahlend erneut der trockene Muskateller, den man in dieser Art so nicht mehr findet in der Pfalz. Das gilt ebenso für die Linie an edelsüßen Gewächsen mit ihrer faszinierenden Klarheit, Opulenz und Fülle.
Pictures: Cellar Tour and Tasting at Weingut Müller Catoir
The Wines we Tasted
We tasted mainly vintage 2014 wines. Stephan Reinhardt (Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | Germany: Vintage 2014: All Along the Rhine River | Dec 31 2015) wrote about the vintage 2014 wines in Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate: "[..]The 2014s Rieslings are simply excellent and the noble sweet Rieslaners are outstanding. Indeed, the wines of MC have become deeper and even more precise and elegant in recent years. I already liked the 2013s, but I was really impressed by the quality and intensity of the 2014s. These are concentrated and well balanced, and come along with moderate alcohol levels which Martin Franzen compares to those of the 1990s. They are true individuals in a very noble and balanced style, although they don't lack tension or expression.[..]"
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Scheurebe VDP.Gutswein
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Haardt Riesling VDP.Ortswein (89+ Parker)
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Bürgergarten Riesling VDP.Erste Lage (92 Parker)
2012 Weingut Müller-Catoir Herrenletten Grauburgunder (im Holzfass gereift) VDP.ErsteLage
2011 Weingut Müller-Catoir Gimmeldinger Riesling Kabinett VDP.Ortswein
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Bürgergarten Im Breumel Riesling Spätlese VDP.GrosseLage (93 Parker)
This outstanding, castle-like impressive estate - visible on the Haardt hill from afar - in the Neustadt suburb of Haardt, the so called balcony of the Pfalz with a very favorable microclimate, has been in the Müller-Catoir family since 1744. For more than a century the winery was managed by women who left a pronounced mark on the estate. Today ninth generation Philipp David Catoir is running the winery.
This was a “walking tasting”. We tasted the wines during the vineyard tour and the cellar tour. Andrea Müller was our host.
Weingut Müller Catoir is in the Theise/ Skurnik portfolio of German wines.
Weingut Müller Catoir
Theise/ Skurnik: Family owned since 1774 with 9 generations tending the vines, the winery is now run by Philipp David Catoir. Martin Franzen, hailing from the Mosel, with experience as head of operations at Schlossgut Diel in the Nahe and Gut Nagelsforst in Baden, took over winemaking responsibility from Hans-Günther Schwarz in 2001. In an effort to showcase terroir and varietal character, Müller-Catoir has adopted the following philosophy of winegrowing: “Vines were grown by natural methods with organic fertilization, permanent green cutting that gets more and more radical every summer, and ever-greater selective harvesting with hand-picking of grapes for even the most “basic” kabinett wine – all these measures cannot help but produce only a small yield of wines with a mineral note, a filigree acidity structure and exotic fruit aromas.” The estate began an organic conversion in 2007 and completed their first organic vintage in 2009. The vineyards in Haardt are composed of primary rock (urgestein) and sandstone, with an increasing proportion of gravel lower on the slopes. Vineyards of Gimmeldingen contain more loess and sand, while the vineyards of Mussbach are the most gravelly. Müller-Catoir also bottles several “micro parcels”; one of which, the Breumel in den Mauern, is a monopole inside the Burgergarten which was first planted 700 years ago, and is also one of the oldest vineyards in the Pfalz.
Müller-Catoir was a pioneer of reductive winemaking in Germany. The estate implements a gentle crush, a long skin contact, slow gentle pressing, and then ferments at warmer than customary fermentation temperatures in stainless steel. The wine is racked only once and very late. Müller-Catoir produces wines of outstanding transparency and density, and remains emblematic of Riesling at its most sophisticated.
Vineyard area: 21 hectares
Annual production: 12,500 cases
Vineyard holdings: Haardt – Bürgergarten, Herzog (both sandstone) and Herrenletten (loam, limestone); Gimmeldingen – Mandelgarten (weathered sandstone and löss): Mußbach – Eselshaut (gravel)
Farming Practice: Certified Organic
Gault Millau WeinGuide Deutschland 2016
Gault Millau WeinGuide Deutschland 2016: Man darf mit Fug und Recht sagen, dass das Weingut Müller-Catoir wie ein Fels in der Brandung steht. Um es herum ist Aktion, Alarm, Mode hier, Trend dort – und Müller-Catoir in aller Ruhe mittendrin, unbeirrt seinen eigenen Stil verfolgend. Der drückt sich etwa darin aus, sich niemandem anzubiedern durch ein möglichst breit aufgestelltes Sortiment – etwas mehr als eine Handvoll Rebsorten genügen hier. Auch die Anzahl der trockenen Rieslinge ist überschaubar: vom Gutswein „MC geht es über Haardt, Bürgergarten und Herrenletten schnurstracks zum Großen Gewächs Im Breumel. Alles fein und klar definiert, durchaus aristokratisch zu nennen. Unglaublich strahlend erneut der trockene Muskateller, den man in dieser Art so nicht mehr findet in der Pfalz. Das gilt ebenso für die Linie an edelsüßen Gewächsen mit ihrer faszinierenden Klarheit, Opulenz und Fülle.
The Wines we Tasted
We tasted mainly vintage 2014 wines. Stephan Reinhardt (Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | Germany: Vintage 2014: All Along the Rhine River | Dec 31 2015) wrote about the vintage 2014 wines in Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate: "[..]The 2014s Rieslings are simply excellent and the noble sweet Rieslaners are outstanding. Indeed, the wines of MC have become deeper and even more precise and elegant in recent years. I already liked the 2013s, but I was really impressed by the quality and intensity of the 2014s. These are concentrated and well balanced, and come along with moderate alcohol levels which Martin Franzen compares to those of the 1990s. They are true individuals in a very noble and balanced style, although they don't lack tension or expression.[..]"
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Scheurebe VDP.Gutswein
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Haardt Riesling VDP.Ortswein (89+ Parker)
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Bürgergarten Riesling VDP.Erste Lage (92 Parker)
2012 Weingut Müller-Catoir Herrenletten Grauburgunder (im Holzfass gereift) VDP.ErsteLage
2011 Weingut Müller-Catoir Gimmeldinger Riesling Kabinett VDP.Ortswein
2014 Weingut Müller-Catoir Bürgergarten Im Breumel Riesling Spätlese VDP.GrosseLage (93 Parker)
Pictures: Vineyard Tour, Cellar Tour and Tasting at Weingut Müller Catoir – Germany-South Tour by ombiasy WineTours (2015)
- schiller-wine: Related Postings
Overview: Rhône Valley 2024 by ombiasy WineTours led by Annette Schiller - Facebook Day-by-day Postings
Overview: Germany Rhein-Mosel-Nahe 2024 by Ombiasy Public Relations and Wine Tours led by Annette Schiller - Facebook Day-by-day Postings
Summary: Loire 2024 - Châteaux and Wine - by ombiasy WineTours, led by Annette Schiller
Summary: Germany "From Berlin to Frankfurt" 2023 (Saale Unstrut, Sachsen, Franken, Württemberg) by ombiasy WineTours
Summary: From Lyon to Paris - Total Immersion in Burgundy and Champagne 2023 by ombiasy WineTours (July 02 - 13, 2023)
Summary: Austria 2023 by ombiasy WineTours - 12 Days: May 28 - June 08, 2023
Christian Schiller`s SCHILLER-WINE Blog on Corking Wines` Top 101 Wine Writers of 2020 List
The 2024 American Wine Society National Conference in Winston-Salem, North Carolina/ USA with Annette and Christian Schiller: Seen Through Christian Schiller's Camera Lens
2022 Annual Riesling Party at the Schiller Residence in McLean, Virginia, USA
Massive Tasting of Bordeaux 1982 - the Vintage that made Robert Parker a Star, USA/ France
Kékfrankos - Blaufränkisch - Lemberger: A Grape’s Immigration Story From Central Europe To The US West Coast - Seminar at the 2023 American Wine Society National Conference in St. Louis/ Missouri/ USA led by Annette Schiller
The New German Wine Law of 2021 - Tasting at the German Wine Society (Washington DC Chapter), presented by Annette Schiller
schiller-wine Blog of Christian Schiller Top Washington DC Alcohol Blog (December, 2024)
2024 Annual Meeting of the Weinfreundeskreis Hochheim, a 45 Years Old Wine Brotherhood in the Famous Wine Village Hochheim, Rheingau, Germany, with Annette Schiller, Founding Member, and Christian Schiller
Masterclass - The Wines of Germany: Presentation by Annette Schiller at the German Embassy in Washington DC/ Consular Conference March 2024
The New German Wine Law of 2021 - Shifting from the Sugar Level at Harvest to the Wine's Geographic Origin
Dinner at JAN in Munich, Germany, with Jan Hartwig, one of the ten German 3-star Michelin Chefs (September 2024)
Hans Rebholz, Weingut Oekonomierat Rebholz, Pfalz, Presenting his Wines at the German Embassy
in Washington DC, USA (January 2025)
2025
Rieslingfeier Gala Dinner in New York City, Sky Loft, 32nd Floor of 50
Hudson Yard, with 15 #worldclass Winemakers from Germany + Austria and Estimated 300
Wines, many 20, 30, 40 Years old, many Larger Format and almost all
Ultra-premium
German Wine Society (Capital Chapter) Membership Meeting 2025: Carl Willner Re-elected
President and Christian Schiller Re-elected Vice-president, USA/ Germany
No comments:
Post a Comment